Open Letter from our CEO David Armstrong
Before anything else I want to congratulate the amazing team at Ascot for staging a royal meeting that had every bit of the drama and excitement we have come to expect despite the difficult circumstances. I would also like to congratulate everyone involved in delivering behind-closed-doors racing so far across the UK.
In light of this and all the good work of the last three weeks, the board of the Racecourse Association was particularly surprised and disappointed to receive a letter from the Horsemen’s Group on June 5, just five days after the successful resumption of racing, making various accusations against the RCA and its members. What was equally disappointing was that a copy of the letter, marked ‘Strictly Private and Confidential’ was subsequently passed to the Racing Post, ensuring that its contents would be widely circulated.
For the record, we consider the allegations and claims made in the letter to be entirely false and without merit and we have replied to the Horsemen’s Group to make these points in the strongest terms. Our reply will not be passed to the Racing Post or any other publication, by us at least, but we could not let the ¬allegations made in its letter pass without comment.
The hard work to reach the point at which racing became the first professional sport to resume in Britain on June 1 was a truly collabor¬ative effort between the Horsemen, the BHA, the Horserace Betting Levy Board and ¬Racecourses, so you can understand our dismay to receive a letter just five days in that seemed so inconsistent with the collaboration that all involved had worked so hard to build.
However, putting all of that to one side, what is the real issue at stake here? The Horsemen’s Group appears to be concerned that racecourses have not been able to resume the payment of Executive Contributions (EC) to prize-money in the initial phase of the resumption plan, correctly pointing out that a large proportion of prize-money over this period is being contributed by the Horserace Betting Levy Board.
It should be put on record, though, that by the end of this week, just the third week of racing since the resumption, Jockey Club ¬Racecourses and Ascot had contributed approximately £2.3m of EC towards prize-money between them.
The issue that the Horsemen’s Group does not appear to have ¬recognised is just how badly -racecourses have been affected by the Covid-19 crisis.
When lockdown began the income of every racecourse stopped overnight. The Government furlough scheme and the ¬suspension of business rates have helped significantly, but even taking those benefits into account, courses were still bearing fixed costs – and therefore losses – of £8.2m per month. That is real cash outflow and, as anyone who has studied the accounts of racecourses at Companies House would discover, the tracks do not have significant cash reserves to enable them to survive a crisis of this nature.
Any profits made by racecourses, after contributions to prize-money, are typically re-invested in industry initiatives and facilities on course, many of which benefit Horsemen.
By the end of 2018, British racecourses had spent roughly £1.35 billion on their facilities over a 20-25 year period, including land, buildings and equipment, but still only earned a low single-digit return on investment – well below any commercial norms.
When racing behind closed doors began the scale of losses barely changed. A typical behind-closed-doors fixture is likely to be little more than a break-even event for a ¬racecourse as income is limited to streaming rights and limited race sponsorship. As well as normal operating costs, each course has to comply with Government Covid-19 guidance and the new BHA protocols which add a significant layer of cost.
In addition, courses have incurred set-up costs to prepare for behind-closed-doors, averaging around £40,000 per racecourse. Failing to make those investments would potentially risk the continuation of racing. Under these circumstances it needs to be understood that survival has been the priority for every track.
The re-opening of retail betting shops this week will help the path to recovery and may enable courses to run a behind-closed-doors fixture profitably, but this does not eliminate the £8.2m per month of fixed costs. In fact, these fixed costs rise as courses unfurlough staff to be able to stage the fixtures and the furlough scheme itself winds down.
The key to the financial strength of courses is the return of crowds to sport. Just over 46 per cent of ¬racecourse income comes from racegoers and during the summer months this rises to nearer 55 per cent. The combination of ticketing, food and beverage and hospitality is vital.
It was with these financial pressures in mind that the Finance Group of the Industry Covid Response set about creating the reduced fixture list, race programme and race values for the initial ten-week resumption period. It was widely accepted at the time that most courses would be unable to contribute EC in this period and most likely until crowds could return. Therefore, the HBLB agreed to fund prize-money during that period based on a new set of minimum values that were published a few weeks ago. The Horsemen’s Group was fully involved in this process and completely aware of the funding plan but raised no objections about courses being unable to contribute EC.
Elsewhere in its letter the Horsemen’s Group claims that the RCA has colluded with the courses and engaged in anti-competitive practices. These claims ignore the true nature of the role of the RCA. It is the courses that independently agree the level of EC to be paid, not the RCA, and the RCA board has never even discussed EC during this crisis.
The Horsemen’s Group also ¬claim that the 2013 Prize Money Agreements between the Horsemen’s Group and racecourses are still in effect despite the fact they ended in December 2017 – the RCA had been trying to facilitate the introduction of new agreements for over a year.
Given the aggressive nature of the letter and the falsehood of the claims, the RCA reluctantly felt it necessary to put forward a full picture of the current situation but we do not wish to engage further in any public comment.
In both the short and long-term, we believe that the RCA and the Horsemen can achieve a great deal more by co-operating and understanding each other than by legal correspondence and negative publicity.